IRELAND 3: Butt and Parnell: 1870-1886
The two leaders in the 1870s of a new legitimate campaign to break the union are members of Ireland’s Protestant ruling class. Isaac Butt has been in his youth a passionate Unionist and, as a successful Dublin lawyer, a leading opponent of DanielO’Connell.
But during the famine of 1845-7 Butt is shocked by the failure of the British government to take effective action, and by the tendency of many Protestant landlords to profit from the appalling situation (by seizing the opportunity to subdivide smallholdings for a greater combined rent). He comes to believe that the situation can only be resolved if Ireland’s parliament is restored.
With this change of heart, Butt immediately becomes a powerful and committed advocate in his new cause. In 1848 he defends the Young Ireland rebels charged with treason for their part in the abortive insurrection of that year. In the second half of the 1860s he often undertakes the defence of arrested Fenians. But his own inclination is for legitimate politics.
Since 1852 he has been, with one interval, an Irish member of parliament at Westminster. In 1870, putting the Home Rule issue at the head of his personal political agenda, he founds the Home Rule association.
During the 1870s the Home Rule cause, led in the house of commons by Isaac Butt, can count on the support of more than fifty members of parliament. Its programme is limited to Irish autonomy in internal affairs, with no demand as yet for the rupture of the union itself.
This soon changes after a much more dynamic figure, Charles Stewart Parnell, is elected member for Meath in 1875. He rapidly takes over from Butt the leadership of the Home Rule party and introduces a more vigorously disruptive policy. This includes active obstruction of parliamentary business at Westminster (to the extent that as many as thirty-six Irish members are at various times suspended) and the fomenting of rural unrest in Ireland.
In 1879 the Irish Land league is founded by Michael Davitt, recently released from a gaol sentence for sending firearms to Ireland for the use of theFenians. The league’s purpose is to promote insurrection among Irish smallholders (the predicament of Captain Boycott is an early result). Parnell becomes president of the league, but he disowns terrorism – in particular the murder in Phoenix Park in 1882 of the new Irish chief secretary, Lord Frederick Cavendish, and his under-secretary.
By 1885 Gladstone is converted to Home Rule for Ireland, partly from a sense of the justice of the cause and partly because the activities of the Irish lobby are making government impossible.
Gladstone and Parnell stand together on the Home Rule bill which Gladstone brings to parliament in 1886. But the issue is deeply unpopular with the English upper classes. It splits Gladsone’s Liberal party just as theCorn Lawsdivided the Conservatives forty years earlier. Liberals in favour of the Union (calling themselves Liberal Unionists, and the origin of the subsequent Unionist party) join with the Conservatives to defeat the government.
Gladstone resigns and devotes himself in the following years to campaigning for the Home Rule cause. He does so in a continuing partnership with Parnell – until scandal intervenes.
